3West Buyer at Goodmores, Exmouth, Asks Developer to Buy Back Her New Build After Around 50 Snags

Buying a brand new home is supposed to mean moving straight in and getting on with life. For one homeowner at the Goodmores development in Exmouth, Devon, the first two months have instead been taken up with snag lists, contractor visits and letters to her developer, and she has now asked the firm to buy the house back.

Amanda Scott, known as Mandy, told the Exmouth Journal that she has reported around 50 snagging issues since completing on her property with local developer 3West on 21 August 2026. She had bought the home off-plan.

Around 50 Snags in Two Months

According to the Exmouth Journal, the problems Mandy describes include walls and ceilings she believes are uneven, a bathroom window sill that she says is not level, poorly fitted toilets, damaged bathroom tiles and paintwork she considers unacceptable. She also says there were drainage problems and a sewage smell in her en-suite bathroom when she moved in.

The back garden had to be replaced because, she believed, the ground had not been properly prepared and was unsafe. She acknowledges that this work has since been carried out, and says some of her other complaints have also been dealt with. However, she claims that new problems have kept appearing as others are resolved, and that repair appointments have sometimes been poorly organised, with contractors arriving without clear instructions or the materials needed to finish the job.

Mandy described the number of snags since she moved in as "endless and unacceptable".

No Chance to Inspect Before Exchange

One detail in Mandy's account will resonate with many off-plan buyers. She says she was not allowed to inspect the property before exchanging contracts, although she attended a demonstration of the home shortly before completion. She told the newspaper that a more thorough inspection would have influenced her decision to go ahead with the purchase.

In correspondence with the developer, she said she felt she had bought "a half finished product" despite paying the full price on completion.

A Request for a Buyback

Mandy says she met Colin Palmer of 3West at her home on 8 October to discuss the outstanding work. One option discussed, according to her correspondence, was for her to appoint her own contractors to carry out the remaining repairs, with the developer covering the cost. She says further issues then came to light, making it hard to pin down the full extent of the work needed. A local builder she consulted advised her to commission an independent survey.

In a formal letter dated 21 October, she challenged the standard of workmanship and the way her complaints had been handled, and repeated her request for 3West to consider buying the house back. She also said she was considering legal action if an acceptable resolution could not be reached. A further disagreement followed a landscaping visit on 23 October, which she says was hampered by confusion over the work required and a shortage of materials.

Mandy says the experience has affected her wellbeing, and that her preferred outcome is for the developer to buy back the property.

What 3West Has Said

A spokesperson for 3West told the Exmouth Journal that the company has been in touch with Mandy, and that the problems she raised have either been fixed or will be fixed shortly.

The newspaper notes that 3West's published customer charter says its new homes undergo a detailed quality inspection before handover, and refers to a two-year warranty and an NHBC 10-year Buildmark warranty.

Lessons for Other New Build Buyers

Every new build will have some snags, but the number reported here, and the frustration of trying to get them fixed while living in the home, show why preparation before completion matters so much.

First, ask about a pre-completion inspection as early as possible, ideally before you exchange, and get the answer in writing. Developers registered with the New Homes Quality Board are expected to follow the New Homes Quality Code, which covers pre-completion inspections, so it is worth checking whether your developer is registered. Spotting problems before you hand over the balance of the purchase price puts you in a far stronger position than reporting them afterwards.

Second, keep a clear record of everything. A single, dated snag list with photographs, copies of every email and letter, and notes of each contractor visit make it much easier to show what has and has not been fixed. This is especially important where new defects keep emerging, as appears to have happened here.

Third, use the developer's complaints process formally. For most new homes the developer is responsible for putting right defects during the first two years. If a dispute cannot be settled, the warranty provider may be able to help; NHBC, for example, offers a resolution service for Buildmark policyholders. Where the developer is registered with the New Homes Quality Code, homeowners can also take an unresolved complaint to the New Homes Ombudsman Service.

Finally, there is no automatic right to make a developer take a home back. Anyone considering that route, or legal action, should take independent legal advice before committing to it.

Mandy's experience follows other recent cases we have reported, including the couple who found 150 faults in their new Countryside home in south Leicestershire. You can read more stories like this on our Snagging News page, and share your own experience on the Snagging Forum.

How Snagging.org Can Help

If you are buying a new build, or have recently moved in, our New Build Snagging Checklist PDF will help you inspect your home room by room. If you are already struggling to get defects put right, New Build Snagging Support gives you access to an experienced inspector from New Build Inspections by telephone or email.

For complete peace of mind, a professional snagging inspection from New Build Inspections with your snag list issued within 48 hours.

Next
Next

Couple Find 150 Faults in New Countryside Home in South Leicestershire